Contents

Gene Presence Absence VariationEdit

Gene presence absence variation (PAV) refers to the phenomenon in which different individuals within a species carry different sets of genes. In many organisms, a portion of the genome is shared by almost everyone (the core genome), while a substantial and biologically meaningful portion is present in some individuals but absent in others (the dispensable or accessory genome). This pattern has deep implications for adaptation, phenotype, and evolution, and it has become a central topic in comparative genomics, functional genetics, and plant and microbial breeding.

PAV is best understood as part of the broader landscape of genome variation, alongside single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) and other forms of structural variation. It emerges from a combination of gene loss, gene gain, duplication, deletion, and horizontal gene transfer, among other processes. The study of PAV often requires moving beyond a single reference genome to a broader framework that captures the diversity of gene content across populations, a concept encapsulated by the idea of a pan-genome.

Core concepts

  • Core vs dispensable genome: A core genome comprises genes found in nearly all individuals of a species, while the dispensable or accessory genome includes genes that are absent in some individuals but present in others. The balance between these components varies across taxa and ecological contexts.
  • Open vs closed pan-genomes: In some species, discovery of new genes continues as more genomes are sequenced, indicating an open pan-genome. In others, the gene set saturates, suggesting a more closed pan-genome. This distinction has practical implications for breeders and conservationists who rely on representative gene sets for selection and management. See pan-genome and core genome for related concepts.
  • Functional categories prone to PAV: Certain gene families are particularly prone to presence/absence, including immune and defense-related genes in animals and plants, as well as large receptor-like gene families in crops that modulate resistance to pathogens. The NB-LRR class in plants is a well-known example of a plant gene family showing strong PAV signals. See NLR for more on this class, and NB-LRR as a common shorthand.
  • Detection and analysis methods: PAV is detected using sequencing data and computational approaches that compare gene content across genomes. Methods include read-depth analysis from short and long reads, de novo genome assemblies, and graph-based representations like pan-genome graphs. See structural variation for related detection strategies and genome assembly for the building blocks of genome-side analyses.

Mechanisms and patterns

  • Gene loss and deletion: Genes may be lost along lineages due to selection, drift, or genomic instability, producing absence in some genomes.
  • Gene gain and horizontal transfer: Particularly in microbes and plants, genes can enter a genome through horizontal gene transfer or rapid duplication events, contributing to the accessory genome.
  • Segmental duplications and rearrangements: Large-scale genomic rearrangements can create or remove gene blocks, changing the gene content between individuals.
  • Epigenetics and annotation challenges: Presence/absence signals can be confounded by sequencing gaps, assembly quality, or annotation differences. Distinguishing truePAV from technical artifacts requires careful experimental design and cross-validation with multiple data types (e.g., long-read sequencing, optical mapping, or transcriptomic evidence). See structural variation and genome assembly for methodological context.

Biological and evolutionary significance

  • In crops and wild relatives: PAV often underpins traits of agricultural importance, such as disease resistance, stress tolerance, and metabolism. The dispensable genome tends to harbor large and diverse gene families that enhance adaptability to variable environments. Maize and wheat, among others, show extensive PAV that has been exploited in breeding programs; see pan-genome and plant breeding for related topics.
  • In microbes: PAV reflects ecological niche adaptation, with gene loss or gain shaping pathogenicity, metabolism, and host interactions. Bacteria and fungi frequently display large-accessory genomes that enable rapid responses to environmental pressures.
  • In animals and humans: While the human genome is largely conserved, notable PAV exists in immune-related regions and other complex loci. For example, variation in certain immune gene clusters can influence pathogen recognition and immune response, illustrating how PAV can contribute to phenotypic diversity. See MHC and KIR for related gene families and their roles in immunity.
  • Evolutionary dynamics: PAV interacts with population history, selection pressures, and ecological context. The dispensable genome can serve as a reservoir of new functions that may become core if they prove advantageous in changing environments, a concept central to pan-genome theory. See population genomics for methods and interpretations in population-level studies.

Applications and data resources

  • Pangenome resources: Researchers build and analyze pan-genomes to capture the full range of gene content across individuals. These resources enable more accurate inference of gene presence/absence patterns and better understanding of genotype–phenotype relationships. See pan-genome and genome for foundational concepts.
  • Sequencing technologies and pipelines: Detecting PAV relies on both short-read and long-read sequencing technologies, each with strengths and limitations. Long reads help resolve complex regions and structural variants, while short reads provide high-throughput depth. See short-read sequencing and long-read sequencing for technology context.
  • Functional validation: Linking PAV to phenotype often requires functional assays, gene expression analyses, and, in plants, field trials to assess how presence/absence influences traits under real-world conditions. See gene expression and functional genomics for related approaches.

Controversies and debates

  • Magnitude of impact on phenotype: A recurring debate centers on how much PAV contributes to measurable phenotypic differences relative to SNPs and regulatory variation. While PAV can explain some differences, especially in traits tied to specific gene families, establishing causality requires careful functional validation.
  • Reference bias and pangenome approaches: Relying on a single reference genome can understate the diversity of gene content. Critics argue that moving toward pan-genome representations is essential for an accurate view of a species’ biology, but this shift also introduces computational complexity and interpretation challenges. See pan-genome for context on alternative representations of genetic diversity.
  • Annotation and functional attribution: Distinguishing true presence/absence from annotation gaps and assembly errors remains a methodological challenge. Misannotated or collapsed regions can masquerade as PAV, leading to over- or underestimation of dispensable genes. See genome annotation and structural variation for methods to address this.
  • Practical implications for breeding and medicine: While PAV has clear relevance for breeding in crops and for understanding immune gene variation in humans, translating presence/absence data into reliable phenotype predictions requires robust, multi-omic integration. See breeding and precision medicine for broader contexts.

See also